Showing posts with label fraud. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fraud. Show all posts

Monday, October 11, 2010

What a $50 million fear and lies campaign buys the Zombies

Read Cal Winslow's excellent article on  the Kaiser fight, why NUHW lost and why standing up to fear -- be it from your boss or your union -- is crucial to making an informed decision. SEIU will spend any amount of money and use lies, fear and employer collusion to keep what is shouldn't have. No wonder organized labor is taking a beating: Americas fastest growing union is going out of it;s way to show how progressive and caring it is!

Thursday, May 13, 2010

Fingerprinting of homecare consumers finally illegal!

Thanks to the unanimous decisions of Assembly Budget Subcommittee #1 on Health and Human Services, chair Assemblymembers Wes Chesbro, Jim Beall (both Democrats) Bob Emmerson and Brian Nestande (both Republicans) the fingerprinting for consumers as an anti-fraud measure is now illegal. Thanks to Marty Omoto for his timely report on this crucial decision.
California Budget Crisis:
Assembly Budget Subcommittee Votes to Rescind Fingerprinting Requirement of IHSS Recipients – Follows Senate Budget Subcommittee Action Last Week
Law Remains In Force Until Full Legislature and Governor Approve It As Part of 2010-2011 State Budget

SACRAMENTO, CALIF (CDCAN) [Updated 05/12/2010  02:50 PM  (Pacific Time)] – The Assembly Budget Subcommittee #1 on Health and Human Services, chaired by Assemblymember Wes Chesbro (Democrat – Eureka, 1st Assembly District) voted  4 to 0 this afternoon to rescind the state law passed as part of the 2009-2010 State Budget last July that requires the fingerprinting of all recipients receiving In-Home Supportive Services (IHSS).  Note: the final vote could change if any missing subcommittee members add their votes to the roll call. 

The action was supported by Democrats Chesbro and Assemblymember Jim Beall and also the subcommittee’s two Republican members, Assemblymember Bob Emmerson and Brian Nestande.

The motion by Assemblymember Chesbro would reject the $8.2 million currently in the 2009-2010 State Budget and $5.6 million funding proposed in the 2010-2011 State Budget and any additional associated funding for purposes of fingerprinting IHSS recipients and shift any unspent money into the budget of the Department of Social Services.  Chesbro’s motion would also create corresponding budget related language (referred to as “budget trailer bill”) that would rescind current state law requiring fingerprinting of all IHSS recipients and also state law that requires their fingerprints on all timesheets of their IHSS worker (provider). 

The action follows a similar vote last week by the Senate Budget Subcommittee #3 on Health and Human Services chaired by Sen. Mark Leno (Democrat – San Francisco).

What The Action Means
·         The action by both subcommittees today and last week is not final and still needs approval of the entire State Senate and Assembly -  and then approval of the Governor.  Those approvals will be part of any overall agreement for the 2010-2011 State Budget which, given the enormous budget deficit, will likely be months away. 
·         The action today would rescind or repeal state law – and the funding to implement it – the requirement for mandatory fingerprinting of all recipients who receive IHSS.  The current state law does allow for certain exemptions of the requirement.  However the fingerprinting law still remains in force until final action on this is given by the full Legislature and approved by the Governor as part of the 2010-2011 State Budget.
·         The requirement to fingerprint all IHSS recipients has not been implemented yet by the Department of Social Services – the state agency that oversees the IHSS program statewide, but is proceeding forward as a pilot in certain parts of the state.  If the full Legislature and Governor end up giving final approval of today’s subcommittee action, the effort to move forward on the pilot would end. 
·         The action today did not address and does not impact the fingerprinting and background checks requirements of IHSS workers (providers) that was  passed as part of the 2009-2010 State Budget last July.  Those requirements went into effect on November 1st and is underway now.

Sunday, April 4, 2010

Revolution Brewing at Local 221

From Monty Kroopkin who is "way down south" at Local 221 (San Diego area). This letter is intended for the members of Local 221 but it gives a peak into the problems the members are dealing with down there. It's good to know the fight for union democracy extends well beyond the NUHW/Zombie UHW fight.
Dear SEIU Brothers and Sisters,

The federal Department of Labor has agreed with incumbent officials of SEIU Local 221 to another extension of the deadline for the Department to file a lawsuit against the union to compel a re-do of the union elections of July 2009. This is the fifth extension of the deadline, which was originally January 17, 2010. The Dept may still reach an out of court settlement with the union, for a new election to be conducted under government supervision. Or, unlikely at this late date, the Dept could still dismiss the complaint which was filed by 10 members of Reform221 on November 16, 2009. The Dept did announce in January that it had made a preliminary finding of serious violations in the 2009 elections.

Meanwhile, the same people who are accused of rigging the July 2009 elections are still in control of our union. That is, with the exception of former Local 221 President Sharon-Frances Moore. She resigned on January 18, 2009, for reasons which the union membership has still not been allowed to hear. Her running mates in the July 2009 elections are still the majority on the union's Executive Board. They voted to appoint Moore's former chief of staff, Eric Banks, as Interim President. Banks also served as the official contact person for the election campaign of Moore's slate of candidates. Moore's slate of candidates were mostly incumbent members of the "provisional" (aka, unelected) E-Board, and were appointed directly by International SEIU President Andy Stern in 2007.

If you don't like the way this is dragging out, and don't like the sound of who is appointing who, then it is time to make your voice heard. Please write to U.S. Dept. of Labor, Office of Labor-Management Standards, District Director Alan Weiss at Weiss.Alan@dol.gov and urge him to get on with resolving this complaint. We need a new election NOW, not years from now!

And, please join Reform221. Our platform is posted on our website at http://reformseiulocal221.blogspot.com/ (scroll down to see it). If you agree with most of what we stand for, we want to work with you to take back our union and to make it effective in dealing with our employers. Contact us at reform221@earthlink.net
 
And come to the first General Membership Meeting of SEIU Local 221, and voice your concerns, on April 17, 2010. Information on the meeting is at the Local website at http://draft.seiu221.org/General_Membership_Meeting.aspx You can introduce resolutions on the direction of our union and/or for particular actions to be taken, which -- if voted in by the members at the meeting -- are binding upon the incumbent Executive Board and the union's staff. Resolutions can be introduced from the floor of the meeting. (So don't be put off by the request to turn yours in by April 7. Those turned in on time will however be printed up so eveybody at the meeting will have a copy). Did you know that you could do that? Did you know members of our union have this power?

For a Democratic and Effective Union,

Monty Kroopkin, Steward
Here's the ruling from the U.S. Department of Labor. It appears Local 221 executive staff will delay the inevitable and further soil the SEIU brand here in California and by extension nationally.

Wednesday, March 31, 2010

Now looks who might be going to jail!

For all the fuss the Zombies made about NUHW leaders going to jail, a Zombie staffer might be the first, and likely only person to actually go to jail. It seems Alex Espinoza a UHW rep and white rapper didn't believe his own oath for honesty while on the stand yesterday and was caught in a lie! Pictured below is Alex, and an excerpt about what he did from the NUHW daily newsletter keeping us all abreast of what is going on in the trial.


Here's what he did:
SEIU rep Alex Espinoza committed perjury-a federal crime punishable with jail time-by lying about his actions in the days before trusteeship. He denied ever contacting anyone with SEIU International, and claimed not to know who Amado David worked for. But NUHW's attorney showed an email Espinoza sent to SEIU International official Amado David just days before the trusteeship that proved Espinoza was secretly spying for SEIU while on UHW's payroll. In lying to the jury, Espinoza damaged SEIU's credibility and put himself at risk of prosecution.
Source:http://www.nuhw.org/trial/day-7-seius-paid-witnesses-lose-credibility.html
So, yes folks, the Zombies are Leading the Way...to jail!

Friday, March 19, 2010

Despite being $20 billion in the hole, Governor finds way to harrass IHSS consumers

I guess it isn't enough that the Governor has had IHSS providers (workers) in his crosshairs since the day he took office. Apparently our (both providers and consumers (clients)) mere existence is unacceptable. Always looking for a new and devastating way to burn his fellow Californians, he's going after IHSS consumers (clients). You know, the low income elderly and disabled not to mention usually frail neighbors and family we care for that are our neighbors, friends and family. My friend's who cares for his father with dementia, my wife with Cerebral Palsy, my friend who cares for her child with Spina Bifida these are the latest group he's added to his list of usual suspects. This man has no conscious: he'll attack the poor and weak to perpetuate the illusion his efforts are saving money. But as I've written before the pennies he's saving are far outweighed by the dollars he's spending. Take, for example, the $3.5 million spent in Sacramento County to find fraud. Nineteen cases of fraud were detected for their efforts. That is a monumental waste of our, the taxpayers, money and an affront to 99% of honest IHSS providers. Now his administration is mulling over the purchase several hundred of these "MorphoTrak 'mobile biometric identification' device[s]". I checked out their website and found 2 devices that seem to fit the description in the Sacramento Bee article. Clearly this is speculative, but these devices seem overpriced and are more like mobile homecare terrorizing devices. Take your pick. What's next: a 1984-esque television that watches back?


See, if the guy gathering your information just smiles at you  it's make the criminalization of your job/disability so much easier to swallow! Seriously what a condescending smirk!

Or how about this one. Why not just go for broke and bring a lie detector to every consumer's house?



I see a few problems with the devices and their use. Here in Sonoma county, and I presume other organized counties, the contract between the county and the union reaffirms the long standing (e.g. before unionization) consumer right to "[d]etermine in advance and under all circumstances who may and may not enter their home." This is from section 3.1 (A) (3) of all contracts since we became organized in Sonoma county. What if a consumer can't come to the door? Hmmmmm. This privacy clause applies to unannounced house visits, but the Zombies are too busy hiring an army of lawyers from 4 law firms to fight NUHW in court next week to care about what really matters.

Second is the cost of these devices. These devices appear to be functionally equivalent to what I've listed below, at a price well below the 5 grand estimated cost of these mobile terrorizing units. Is this the best the Governator can come up with to fight fraud and save money? He can have both without spending a fortune of taxpayers money (which is not his money).

Finger print scanner: $39-$64
Digital camera: $29 & up
Netbook (a stripped down notebook computer): $250 & up (or better yet this one)

Add them up and what do you get, outside of a vendor who found a pot of gold hiding in the state budget?


 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
\ /


$318 (just under $350 with tax)

The software to operate the fingerprint reader is included with the reader itself and any computer from 2001 forward can retrieve pictures from a digital camera with any additional software.

Finally, as stated in the article the new legislation does not mention photographing consumers. Sounds like the State is getting in on the harassment of consumers normally performed by fraudsters.


So it appears that yet again the Governator's plans to destroy homecare will cost far money than it can ever hope to save. I'm so happy he's terming out of office next year.

Wednesday, February 17, 2010

"Sure you're disabled, just not disabled enough!"

Below is the first article I've read this budget season that describes the way in which the Governator wants to destroy homecare and the affect it would have on the lives of consumers (clients). With all the negative press that focuses on just the costs and the race occurrence of fraud it's refreshing to see someone other than me touting the economic and social benefits of homecare. It's not just a grueling job, it's a job that saves money and saves live: consumers, providers (worker) and both their families all benefit from non-institutionalized care of our disabled poor. Can't the Governator see that cutting care would make the disabled suffer, the workers jobless and the families overburdened with care often to their own financial detriment?

The Functional Index (FI) score was designed to quantify individual disability, not determine categorical eligibility. To use it as such is, at best, reprehensible. One would not have to look far to find obvious exceptions and contradictions to this line of reasoning. For example my wife has never and will never walk but her FI score is above a friend of ours who can walk with a walker but is much more dependent upon her caregiver. Should our friend become ineligible just because her FI score is lower? Is rating and then discriminating against the disabled the best solution the State can come up with to balance the budget? We need to ask our Legislature and Governator to do better than to pick on the poor and defenseless.

Wednesday, February 10, 2010

Homecare fraud: you're lucky if you can find it!

Recently there has been some press coverage about homecare fraud with nearly all of it being bad. If we didn't get bad press we'd get no press at all. It seems the nature and cost effectiveness of homecare is horribly misunderstood. If you follow the LameStream media's coverage of this attack on homecare you'd think that the disabled poor and those who care for them are criminals worthy of only the harshest treatment. Following the Governator's line of reasoning one might think were it not for homecare the State wouldn't have a budget deficit at all! Here's an example of the spoon-fed and lopsided thinking that makes my blood boil.

 

This is exactly what we don't need: division among the consumers (clients) as to who is eligible. Having met several homecare providers (workers) and their consumers I can tell you if a consumer is receiving homecare services it's vital to the well-being and happiness of the consumer. My wife is much happier living with me than living in a group home! Homecare is no road to riches for the providers and it saves the State far more than it would spend if it housed every consumer in a nursing home, group home or whatever dungeon they think the disabled poor should be warehoused in.

When legislators and journalists stop blindly accepting what someone else tells them is the irrefutable truth (the Gov tells the Legislature, and the journalists gobble up whatever they hear from Sacramento) and the State attempst to find the fraud, they find much less fraud exists than is reported by the media. In 2007, the Gov stated it was as high as 25%, but when investigated by his own administration it was found to be no more than 1%. Don't get me wrong: even 1% is unacceptable but the way the State is going about reducing fraud is Draconian, and obviously lopsided (which is putting it nicely). For those who choose to abuse the system and steal from both us the taxpayers and us the overwhelmingly majority of honest workers just trying to earn a living, I say hang them up by their ampersand caret asterisk toes in the middle of town.

The money spent to detect and stop fraud is ridiculous in both absolute dollars and when the amount of money recovered is divided into the amount spent finding the fraud in the first place. Here are some examples:

 

Did y'all get that: they spent $3 million to save $315,000! That's $157,894.74 per conviction! I thought the Zombies' dollar-to-vote ratio was out of control but this is ridiculous! A quick run crunching the numbers shows this was a prime example of the State's penny-wise but pound-foolish approach to handling our tax money.
Maximum number of hours that can be assigned to any one consumer: 283 (a 40 work week is 173 hours a month, 283 is ~1.6 times more)
Hourly wage for IHSS workers in Sacramento: $10.40
Months in a year: 12
A years worth of homecare work at the above given wage comes out to $35,318.40
Difference between cost per conviction and maximum payout for one consumer's worth of work (283 x 10.40 x 12=): $110,576.34.

I say (s)he who wastes more money gets required lifetime employment at McDonald's working the drive thru window!

So, yet again way more money is spent than is recovered, but at least the politicians can feel good about their efforts to root out the fraud. Sheesh, does it hurt to be this stupid?

This is not an isolated example of the State's overzealous attack on the poor and defenseless.

 

So as you can see the State is very concerned about the 0.2% (NOT 2%!) in over-payments in Fresno county, the State's leader in homecare fraud detection, prevention and conviction and the only way they can see to fix the problem and punish this despicable and very small group of scamming "caregivers" is to take us all down. Make the poor poorer (reduce us to minimum wage), punish the innocent (fingerprinting for all), surely that will solve all our problems!

So to combat this problem they've written the "improvements" below into law. As far as I know they have yet to figure out how to implement these new laws. What the State has in mind is indeed punitive:
  • checks can't be mailed to P.O. boxes (which is a bummer because in my neighborhood, a P.O. box is an excellent way to prevent identity theft)
  • fingerprints for both the provider and consumer put on each timecard (Who pays for the ink? Who is charged with matching 800,000+ fingerprints to people on a semi-monthly basis? What if a consumer doesn't have (accessible) thumbs? Whatever happened to "innocent until proven guilty"?)
  • State required but not funded fingerprinting for both consumers and providers (and where were the Zombies when these proposal became law? Busy fighting with members, again!)
  • unannounced home visits (Which seem to be in violation of  multiple homecare contracts about the consumer's right to chose whom, how and when someone enters their home.)
Seems like overkill doesn't it?

A few things need to be said about fraud:
  • fraud is wrong, no matter the justification or significance
  • those who commit fraud, both providers and (living) consumers must be punished
  • the rest of us who aren't committing fraud need to be left alone, no fingerprinting at our own expense to prove our innocence
  • the folks handling the timecards (counties) and the folks who cut the checks (the State) need some simple checks to be put in place, specifically:
  • no checks for the consumers known to be deceased (except for consumers who passed away mid pay period)
  • no checks for providers or consumers who are in jail
Had the counties and the State been checking for this all along who knows how much money could have been saved. Consider the lack of seething animosity that could have been avoided. The oft reported, but grossly exaggerated costs of IHSS fraud could simply never have happened but for that you'd need a state that cares for it's elderly and disabled poor, instead of taking every possible action to move us both ever-faster into the grave. Even when these fraudsters are caught it's a great expense to the State and the money is not always recovered.

Fortunately for us all the writing of a few bright minds makes it's way to the Op-Ed sections of our newspapers and blogs.


Indeed, this is a rare voice of reason is a sea of stupity.

Friday, February 5, 2010

Scam Artists Posing as IHSS Fraud Investigators

From the California Progress Report is a report from Noreen Evans (Democrat is State Assembly, 7th District). Spread the word and watch out everyone, the Governator's plan for killing the poor and disabled has yet another bit of collateral damage for or which we must all be aware.

 

Thursday, November 12, 2009

62 pages of smoking gun goodness

Remember my earlier post about how the hammer was about to be dropped on the UHW camp? Well here it is folks, NUHW has the goods on SEIU's criminal and frequent misdoings in Fresno. Packed full of legal defenses of NUHW's claims against the Zombies, declarations by both NUHW staff and former Zombie staff members (whom implicated themselves in an attempt to come clean). The good stuff begins with declarations from a few IHSS workers who had the courage to step forward and describe the hell they went through because of the Zombies, and of course the smoking gun itself: "Winning in Fresno: Some Tips for Success" (last page of the lawsuit).




So first off is a Table-O-Contents, using the page numbers shown when viewing the documents as a PDF. A print out will not show the page numbers I have listed below. Exhibits 1-5 not in this document.

Section
Pages
Summary by NUHW

1-3
Response to the Zombies "position paper", proof of service
4-10,11
Exhibit 6: Defense of election results as seen from the Department of Industrial Relations, "...and the winner is:"
12, 13-14, 15
Exhibit 7: Signed Supplemental Declaration from NUHW Director of Long Term Care Division John Vellardita
16, 17-19

Exhibit 8: Signed declaration from Carlos Martinez, former Zombie staff member
20, 21-26

Exhibit 9: Signed declaration from Andriana Gomez, Fresno IHSS (homecare) worker
27, 28-29

Exhibit 10: Signed declaration from Sheri Davis, Fresno IHSS worker
30, 31-33
Exhibit 11: English declaration from Patricia Barbosa Rodriguez, Fresno IHSS worker
34, 35-37
Spanish to English translation certification from TransPerfect for Rodriguez
38
Rodriguez's signed original declaration in Spanish
39-42
Exhibit 12: Signed declaration from Mary Townsend, Fresno IHSS (homecare) worker
43, 44-46
Exhibit 13: English declaration from Irma Orozco Fresno IHSS (homecare) worker
47,48-49
Spanish to English translation certification from TransPerfect for Orozco
52
Orozco's original declaration in Spanish
53-55
Exhibit 14: Signed declaration from Richard O'Brien, SEIU staff from SEIU Healthcare PA (Pennsylvania)
56,57
Exhibit 15: Signed declaration of Alexandra Early, SEIU staff from the Fresno fight
58,59-60
SEIU's very incriminating handout: "Winning in Fresno: Some Tips for Success".                                                      
61-62

Whew! Ok, that's done so let us dig in to this pile of garbage and see what juicy nuggets of Zombie fear-mongering we can dig up.

It appears that all the reports on PerezStern and ¡Adios Andy! were right on the money. Was there ever any doubt in your mind?

In one of it's more desperate moments the Zombies tried to challenge the PERB's (Public Employees Relations Board our equivalent of the NLRB, the National Relations Board) "jurisdiction to resolve the allegations raised by NUHW". What the...? Huh? Isn't that like a criminal trying to convince a cop that she doesn't have the authority to arrest the criminal? Since when does SEIU get to the the PERB where and how to do it's job?

NUHW supports its reasoning with a quote from the Meyers-Milias-Brown Act (MMBA). Section 3309(c) states: "unfair practice charges made during an election shall be submitted to the Public Employee Relations Board for resolution." Hah! Take that you misquoting-for-your-own-gain criminals! Never fear: the Zombies will misquote again, keep reading!



Nearly a month after the election, the State Department of Industrial Relations sealed the fate of 10,000 fellow homecare workers in Fresno was sealed. I wish I knew at the time the Zombie had similar plans for Sonoma homecare workers.



Can you imagine how the ruse pulled on Mr. Roose is going to backfire on the Zombies?

Ok get ready to kick it up a notch. Below is Vellardita's (partial?) laundry list of complaints against SEIU. For those playing along at home mark this on your score card and check them off as further proof of SEIU bully-the-workers-party in Fresno sees the light of day. For the party hardy readers: drink 1 shot of the good stuff for each claim that proves to be true in the coming months. As soon as I know it will be here on the Red Revolt within hours.



But what good is a claim without substantial evidence to back it up? Enter the signed declaration of former (and quite remorseful) SEIU interloper and scab Carlos Martinez. While here in California, his boss Rebecca Mahlberg subtly  instructed him to work against the good of the homecare workers they were so desperate to "represent". Here Mahlberg shows what she is really made of, and it's not sugar and spice and everything nice!





Just words so far, right? It's illegal for an union employee or volunteer under their direction to handle a ballot or the envelope, period. Can words describe the reprehensible actions of the union we all pays dues to?

At one point in the campaign the Purple Plague needs someone for on the spot Spanish to English translations. Who does it? Martinez. What do they do after translation? Well, this is their first major assault on unrepresented workers so they weren't taking any chances on playing a fair game, so I'm sure you can figure out what happened to at least one translation.



Ok, so I found some words. Unmitigated arrogance, and brazen inhumanity to fellow man. So a college educated white woman sees fit to act like a child? I can't imagine what kind of social criminal works for SEIU when oppression like this happens. This appear to be a turning point in Martinez' understanding of the kind of morally corrupt outfit he is working for. I applaud him for trying to get the word out, but as you can see when your dues money goes to elect a president it's very hard to get anyone to investigate that same union.


 
Note the 3 federal government officials that didn't act on Martinez's pleas for help. How much abuse must the workers endure before somebody in power steps up?! Good thing we have some on our side! Go Red team!

Here are several clips of workers having their voting supervised and the accompanying harassment. To follow a  worker to the post office is both a sign of desperation and downright creepy, so is the supervised voting, initialing ballots, persuasion to change their vote, etc. For any vote any where it should be done alone, with help from any party on the ballot. SEIU doesn't see it this way as shown here.

From Fresno IHSS (homecare) worker Adriana Gomez's declaration (translated from Spanish):



From fellow Fresno homecare worker Sheri Davis.



Creepy, huh? Unfortunately for these workers SEIU "forgot" (see below) to tell them that benefits are negotiated by but not administered by the union. They go step further in the next quote. In it, they claim to be able to reduce a consumer's (patient's) hours as punishment for not voting for SEIU, yet I am certain that in every contract SEIU has negotiated in California for homecare providers (workers) in California including here in Sonoma county, the consumer's determines who to fire and hire. They are using the ignorance of the members against them. Is that union you'd vote for?

From Patricia Barbosa Rodriguez (translated from Spanish):


I've always believed that in a fight the loser always fights harder, and they are fighting pretty hard to keep what they should have lost.

The end is near folks: for both this entry and the Purple Plague.

Ok everybody the bullet is in the chamber now. Read this declaration from a former staff member to get an inside look on the trickery the Purple Plague pulled in Fresno.



From Alexandra Early, O'Brien's subordinate.



 Finally, here is the smoking gun. Enjoy!

 

 


Wednesday, November 11, 2009

Wall Street Journal: New Salvo Fired as Unions Battle Over Workers

For the Wall Street Journal's perspective on the Fresno fight, read here.

Irrespective of which union you favor or how you feel about organized labor, this much can be said about this absurd fight for representation: if SEIU had a decent approach to organizing and member representation we wouldn't be in this mess. In fact, their strategy is to grow for the sake of growth by adding members as fast a possible then leaving them to fend for themselves. How do I know? Just ask any homecare worker, anywhere or any UHW member that has had a contract renegotiated since SEIU hijacked our local in January 2009. SEIU is not good for workers and not good for America, no matter how you slice it.


Wall Street Journal: California Labor Wars

Well now the Zombies cover has been blown! Finally, an SEIU staffer had the courage and decency to step forward with his recollection of what he and likely all of the other scabs in Fresno were asked to do against their own sense of decency. What we all suspected happened in Fresno has been written up in the Wall Street Journal. I wonder how the Zombies will play this one down and if another election for Fresno homecare workers in the works. I say save everyone a whole bunch of trouble and just let the battered homecare workers of Fresno have what they wanted all along: NUHW!


Sunday, November 8, 2009

Major news on the horizon...

I don't want to post until I see the something of substance but when speaking with Sal Rosselli, interim President of NUHW tonight at the panel discussion he stated a legal action next week could turn Zombie UHW upside down. I don't mean in the way they are doing now with sellout contracts, member intimidation, and so on but I mean run around in a sweat-drenched panic like your hair is on fire because as a Zombie staffer it's less painful than the hell your Zombie overlords are about to put you through kind of life changing news.

Now was that a mouthful? It sure was. Run-on sentence? Almost.

Shown below is what I predict will be a typical Zombie UHW staffer will look like once the legal action is widely known. (My apologies to those with artistic sense that are offended; "The Scream" seems appropriate to me.)

Have a good weekend y'all. I'm going to go watch "Capitalism: A Love Story" with my wife of 5 months.

Wednesday, October 21, 2009

When dealing with SEIU it's good to know we're not alone

Not a whole lot of explanation needed here folks, just watch and learn about how not only Sonoma county homecare workers but also the Sonoma County Board of Supervisors are horrified about SEIU's recent rigged  contract ratification. Normally, labor and management and laborers are opposed but here is a rare example of labor AND management telling the union it's actions and treatment of it's members is reprehensible.


Monday, October 12, 2009

Homecare workers reject SEIU secret contract

After the ratification vote but before the Sonoma County Board of Supervisors (BoS) rubber stamped the fraudulent contract ratification, some UHW propaganda resistant homecare workers plead with the BoS to hold off their approval until a fair ratification was held.



Sadly, the BoS held fast to their assertion that they bargained a great contract. Although they were outraged at the actions of SEIU staff and the bargaining team members, they felt their hands were tied.

Sonoma County homecare workers sound off about about secret contract ratification

Here are the few Sonoma county homecare workers who won't let themselves be blindsided by SEIU's secretive bargaining. You can see what were up against!
 

Homecare veteran speaks about the voting horror

Dozens of homecare providers are calling on Sonoma County Supervisors to investigate SEIU's reported strong-arm tactics in a recent contract ratification vote. I spoke with Arin Stevens; she's been a Sonoma County in-home supportive service provider for 22 years.  She explained not only the background in this story, but the intimidation she witnessed at the polls.


Santa Rosa Memorial veteran hospital employee speak of SEIU UHW West's utter failure in organizing

The North Bay Labor Council is now getting involved in the dispute over two labor unions. A letter was sent out to the trustees of SEIU-UHW asking them not to delay or obstruct efforts by workers at Santa Rosa Memorial Hospital to form a union with the National Union of Healthcare Workers or NUHW.  Nancy Timberlake works in the trauma unit at Santa Rosa Memorial and explains what's happened.


Saturday, October 3, 2009

One perspective to the homecare bargaining "process"

My recollections of the bargaining process/cycle.

On March 16, 2009 I emailed a marked up copy of the 2007-2009 contract to Reefah's UHW and personal email addresses. I never received a response to this email. I have not been able to see if any of my suggested changes made it into the contract, since a copy of the contract is still quite difficult to obtain.

Next up was a “steward meeting” consisting of the 2 remaining stewards Mark Nelson and Anita Torres who according to Reefah decided that any UHW member supporting NUHW was not allowed onto UHW financed charter buses, etc. I think this is when UHW decided to bargain in secret and to keep the TA away from all but the most persistent members and then only on the night of the vote.

I received a mailer asking for me to circle the 4 things most important to me (wages, benefits, etc) and include my name and contact info if I wanted to be on the bargaining team; no response to my interest in the latter.

By now we knew bargaining was happening, but had no clue as to that was going on since, I suspect the bargaining team members weren't exposed to the ground rules of bargaining and therefore did not know that discussion of bargaining with principals (team member to fellow homecare worker) was allowed. Four of the eight bargaining team members were previous NUHW supporters: Alan Shuman, Mark Nelson, Anita Torres and Karen Timmons. (As keeper of the decert petitions I can prove this!)

From here on out to the election there was a great deal of secrecy until the Labor Day Breakfast at the labor center on Corby Avenue (in Santa Rosa) when Karen Timmons named all of the bargaining members and leaked a few details: the wage reduction when the ARRA funded FMAP money runs out and the likely change in health insurance to United Healthcare should Kaiser rates increase “a lot”

Next up was the election meetings themselves with Mark Nelson pushing around a smaller woman at the Healdsburg library, him telling me “I don't like that” when I took a picture of the ballot at the Petaluma community center. The county Board of Supes found this picture quite shocking because of it's wording. Marie White, our very active and educated (former lawyer for the disabled) 85-year old supporter was blocked from voting until, I believe, a threat to call the cops allowed her in the building being guarded by at least 2 quite muscular guards.

When I met with Gustavo I reminded him I was still a member of UHW, pay my dues and just because I am a dissenter doesn't mean viewing the TA was forbidden. He relented and retrieved the TA but wouldn't let go of it at first. He wanted to narrate; I wanted to read it to and for myself. I told him he was bigger than me, much bigger and I'm not going to run off with the contract; this convinced him to not keep his death grip on the TA.

As good as getting the TA may have been for our cause I believe UHW's spin on it would cause more damage than the advantage we'd have if we had the TA in hand before the end of the vote.

The vote itself was on a ballot that didn't go in an envelope that would disguise the vote until the vote count, went in a cardboard box and all votes would be counted by UHW with no impartial observer. UHW claims exactly 90% in favor, not a more believable lie like 91.2%.

Wednesday, September 30, 2009

When SEIU claims ignorance, don't believe them!

Arin Stevens, a Sonoma county homecare worker of 22 years, wrote the following email to Shareefah "Reefah" Joseph, field representative for Sonoma County IHSS providers; Gustavo Corral, her supervisor; Leon Chow, Director of Homecare and UHW trustees Dave Regan and Eliseo Medina.

Notice how only Gustavo answers instead of Shareffah and Dave, Leon and Eliseo never bother to reply. Also notice the evasive and patronizing response from Gustavo.

This is Arin's first email. I won't sum it up as it speaks for itself.
From: heyarin heyarin@sonic.net
Date: Tue, 15 Sep 2009 16:34:14 -0700
To: Shareefah Joseph sjoseph@seiu-uhw.org, Gustavo Corral
gcorral@seiu-uhw.org, "L. Chow" lchow@seiu-uhw.org, "E. Medina"
emedina@seiu-uhw.org, "D. Regan" dregan@seiu-uhw.org
Conversation: Sonoma Co. IHSS contract and vote
Subject: Sonoma Co. IHSS contract and vote

Dear Ms. Joseph,

I understand from talking with another homecare worker today that SEIU UHW intends to bar members from the upcoming contract ratification vote if they, like myself, have exercised our rights by signing petitions to decertify SEIU. In addition, members have been denied copies of the tentative agreement to study before the vote and we still haven't been informed if we're being switched from our Kaiser health coverage to a United Healthcare plan. Members receiving on-going medical treatment or who are scheduled for surgery are very concerned about life threatening interruptions in their care and about finding a doctor with an open practice on short notice.

You have stated that the contract ratification vote will take place at three separate meetings instead of by a mailed ballot. Requiring homecare workers to attend meetings in order to be informed about the TA [tentative agreement] and to vote on it disenfranchises many of our 3000 members. It's especially hard on those who must travel in from outlying areas and workers who cannot leave their IHSS clients until they find a qualified substitute. Mailing postcards this week about next week's meetings doesn't give us enough time to make arrangements to participate and does not constitute adequate notice.

We worked very hard to bring in a union and when I served on the first bargaining committee we kept members regularly apprised of our progress toward that contract. The TA was available to all and our ratification votewas carried out by mail-in ballots as have all subsequent votes therefore I am requesting on behalf of all Sonoma County IHSS workers that SEIU observe its past practices in this county and mail out ballots for contract ratification and to make available to all workers requesting one a complete copy of the tentative agreement with the county for our bargaining unit by the close of the business day tomorrow, Sept. 16th, 2009. To do any less confirms that SEIU is hiding a substandard agreement from us.


Yours truly,

Arin Stevens

Sonoma County IHSS worker
Next up is Gustavo's response.
From: Gustavo Corral gcorral@seiu-uhw.org
Date: Wed, 16 Sep 2009 07:52:43 -0700
To: heyarin heyarin@sonic.net, Shareefah Joseph sjoseph@seiu-uhw.org,
Leon Chow lchow@seiu-uhw.org, "E. Medina" emedina@seiu-uhw.org, Dave
Regan dregan@seiu-uhw.org
Cc: Gustavo Corral gcorral@seiu-uhw.org
Conversation: Sonoma Co. IHSS contract and vote
Subject: RE: Sonoma Co. IHSS contract and vote

Hello Arin,

First, I hope you and Caterine are doing well. Second, I apologize for interjecting on your letter to Reefah. However, since you included me in this email and since I've been part of the entire bargaining process in Sonoma I feel the responsibility to respond and clarify some of your concerns.

As you may or may not know, before beginning negotiations, members of the bargaining team were elected at different membership meetings held throughout Sonoma County. We surveyed all Sonoma homecare providers through a mail-in survey on the top priorities the members wanted the bargaining team to bargain for.

The bargaining team members who were elected have been participating consistently throughout the process, including counting and tallying the surveys. As a result, they knew what the top priorities of the membership were after finishing the count, which created a negotiation platform for the team.

In addition, the bargaining team decided to hold this ratification differently because our contract expires on September 30 and we would not have had enough time to ratify it by mail. Thus, Sonoma members would have been left without a contract. Given the financial crisis that the State and County are facing these days, if Sonoma members had been left without a contract, the members would have been vulnerable for some drastic cuts. It seemed like the county intended to make drastic cuts because before negotiations began, the county sent all homecare workers a notice announcing a wage cut (you may have received this notice as well).

The bargaining team is a very coherent and cohesive group of members working very diligently and looking after the entire membership, not just a few individuals, sometimes sacrificing personal benefit on the decisions they've made.

All homecare members in good standing with the union in Sonoma County including you if that it's the case, are encouraged to attend and vote at any of the three locations: South, Central, and North Sonoma County. You should be getting a notice in the mail soon.

Lastly, I want to say that I have always respected and appreciated your contributions to the union as you were active in the past. The bargaining team needs your support to ratify this contract just like you needed them years ago when you were a bargaining team member. They've done a great job, and I'm sure any of them will gladly explain to you the TA we have reached with the Sonoma PA.

Take care,

Gustavo Corral
Homecare Division
SEIU-UHW
PH 415-503-5704
Fax 415-563-9914
www.seiu-uhw.org
Arin takes another whack at it.
From: heyarin heyarin@sonic.net
Date: Wed, 16 Sep 2009 14:20:27 -0700
To: Gustavo Corral gcorral@seiu-uhw.org
Cc: Shareefah Joseph sjoseph@seiu-uhw.org, "L. Chow" lchow@seiu-uhw.org,
"E. Medina" emedina@seiu-uhw.org, "D. Regan" dregan@seiu-uhw.org
Conversation: Sonoma Co. IHSS contract and vote
Subject: Re: Sonoma Co. IHSS contract and vote

Hello Gustavo,

I appreciate your timely response to my concerns and I also hope you and your family are well. Your reply raises more questions and concerns regarding the contract negotiations and ratification process in Sonoma County.

I was not notified by mail, email or phone message of any meetings to elect a bargaining team in my area and after calling several other members in other parts of the county I found only one who received notification. Everyone did receive the bargaining survey and most of us returned it. When did these meetings occur? What types of notices went out and why were some members notified and not others? How can the bargaining team accurately reflect the membership of our bargaining unit when not all members were notified of an opportunity to participate?

The contract's expiration date was common knowledge so I am wondering why bargaining did not begin sooner? It's normal to file for an extension of the contract to protect members while bargaining continues so was the team ever informed of this practice?

As to the bargaining team making the decision to hold meetings instead of a mail-in ballot to ratify the contract: why have they and SEIU staff chosen to disenfranchise so many members? Are they so unaware of the difficult conditions for many workers and their clients that they would deliberately sacrifice these members' voices in order to rush through a contract?

I've spoken to two members of your bargaining team who either can't and/or won't answer questions about the health care plan changes and the wage reopener. Who on the team truly understands these issues? Would you provide their contact information? And why are complete copies of the entire contract being withheld from members? Many locals post their TAs on-line and make paper copies available so why the secrecy around our TA? And, again, why the deviation from past contract ratification practices which gave every member the opportunity to vote?

Another concern I have with these ratification meetings is the format. Who is running them? Can we bring our consumers? Will civility guide the proceedings or will those with questions and concerns be shouted down or booed or ignored? How will we actually vote? Paper ballots? Show of hands? Voice vote? How will the votes be tallied? How will the results be announced? Will an independent observer verify the results?

Once again I'm requesting a complete copy of our proposed contract to be available today to members for study before the vote and asking that SEIU honor its own past practices and return to a mail-in ballot. Homecare workers should not be forced to travel long distances, travel at their own expense, pay for substitute caregivers or give up working hours so we can vote. This type of disenfranchisement and discrimination in civil elections would today never go unchallenged so why does SEIU treat homecare members this way? We deserve the right to vote privately and without coercion or intimidation or undue burdens of travel and expense. If you and the team have truly bargained a good contract then it will withstand examination and a vote by all members not just the minority that can attend meetings. I look forward to your response to these questions and concerns.

Yours truly,

Arin Stevens

Sonoma County IHSS Provider
And finally Gustavo writes back but says nothing.
From: Gustavo Corral gcorral@seiu-uhw.org
Date: Thu, 17 Sep 2009 17:13:22 -0700
To: heyarin heyarin@sonic.net
Cc: Shareefah Joseph sjoseph@seiu-uhw.org, Leon Chow lchow@seiu-uhw.org,
"E. Medina" emedina@seiu-uhw.org, Dave Regan dregan@seiu-uhw.org
Conversation: Sonoma Co. IHSS contract and vote
Subject: RE: Sonoma Co. IHSS contract and vote

Hello Arin,

In response to your email, as I stated before all members in good standing
will be eligible to vote to ratify the Sonoma IHSS agreement. Good standing
means that as of the last paid period workers have paid their union dues and
have remained members of SEIU UHW and are IHSS providers in Sonoma County.
Again, we hope to see you there. By now you should have gotten the notice.

Thanks,

Gustavo Corral
Homecare Division
SEIU-UHW
PH 415-503-5704
Fax 415-563-9914
www.seiu-uhw.org
So as you can see Arin asks Gustavo, a 10 year veteran of Local 250 turned UHW then Zombie UHW, many questions but gets few answers. And some of those questions receive radically different answers if you ask Gustavo in person.

Saturday, September 26, 2009

Homecare ballot revealed

Here's the ballot for this week's pseudo-ratification. In case you missed the mailer or phone call from Zombie UHW it was Tuesday at the community center in Petaluma, Wednesday at the library in Healdsburg and Thursday at the Santa Rosa UHW homecare office all from 4-6 PM. So 6 hours total to ratify all during rush hour/dinner prep time.




Here's what is says. Emphasis added by me.

"Sonoma County IHSS Public Authority                      UHW
"Ratification Vote                  United Healthcare Workers
September 22, 23, and 24, 2009            ============== West

"YES! I vote to accept the agreement recommended by the bargaining team.

"NO, I reject the agreement and direct the team to return to the bargaining table. I understand that if we reject the agreement, the employer can propose different terms that may be worse for providers and that we can got [sic] for an extended period without wages and benefits protected by a contract."

Their claims for voters who vote no are completely false. Should the contract have expired the wages and benefits would have stayed the same until a replacement contract was ratified or NUHW filed a petition to change representation. Between going back and negotiating a contract without huge giveaways or losing 4700+ dues paying members, which do you think SEIU feared more?

This ratification was flawed in 3 major ways.

Strike 1. From what I've heard a great number of people weren't mailed and/or called.

Strike 2. A mail-in ballot would have been MUCH more convenient especially for anyone who does not live in the above mentioned cities, doesn't have a car, and/or can't get the time off work to vote.

Strike 3. Finally, those who were aware of the vote and showed up but weren't willing to blindly vote yes were subject to harassment, intimidation, and under no circumstances allowed to read the tentative agreement without Zombie UHW staff sitting right next to them.

This would never have happened when UHW was under democratic control. Ahhhh, the good old days!

Here's the flier bargaining team members and Zombie UHW staff handed voters upon entering the room for a "consultation".






I knew they were holding back on something, and now the whole world can just what SEIU was holding back.