In what is sure to be one of many mailers from Zombie UHW aimed at
re-winning the hearts and minds of Memorial workers, the Zombies mailed this bit of garbage. As you can see it uses the same tired and misleading arguments we've all heard since January 2009. Let's dissect this stinker, hold it up to the light and see it for what it really is: a message that came from the wrong union and came too late to make a difference for SEIU.
Who is NUHW?
The people who run NUHW were removed from office for misusing the members' dues money.
No, they were removed for not allowing the forced transfer of 65,000 homecare members from UHW to ULTCW. At the time UHW was a model local union and ULTCW was (and still is) reeling from their own corruption But the dues money used so far to negotiate sellout contracts (
here,
here and
here) since the trusteeship began couldn't possibly be called misuse -- oh, no, no, no. Don't get me started on the
fight for Fresno homecare workers, and the $10 million the Zombies spent there (at ~
$3600+ per vote) to barely "win" an election, where SEIU claimed to have 5,000 -- an absolute majority of votes. Ugh, it makes me sick!
In January, NUHW leaders (then officers of SEIU-UHW) were found guilty by former U.S. Secretary of Labor Ray Marshall of misuing members' dues money and were removed from office. The very next day, they formed NUHW.
To me, this bit of crafty wording seems to imply that Secretary Marshall removed them from office, which is outside his authority reach or interest. Also, page 96 of
Marshall's report states: " [...]
I do not recommend imposing a trusteeship on these grounds at this time because these actions were merely symptoms of the basic underlying cause of the conflict between UHW and the International Union–the jurisdictional conflict over long-term care workers
."
Once the leaders of the pre-trusteeship leaders of UHW realized that Rosselli's proclamation stating democracy "democracy dies in the darkness" had come true and UHW by extension and SEIU was a sinking ship, they headed for higher grounds.
What Did the NUHW Leaders Do Wrong?
Since their removal from office, union members have found out that NUHW leaders:
- Transferred $3 million in members' dues money to a bogus non-profit for their own use.
This should in no way be confused with the blatant misuse of dues money perpetrated by
Tyrone Freeman one of SEIU International President Andy Stern's appointed (NOT elected) local leaders. Also, setting up a mechanism for defending itself from the tyranny of SEIU International can only considered wrong
- Stole thousands of dollars of union property and destroyed files needed to protect workers against management.
This is an unsubstantiated allegation. Assuming it happened you'd think it would have been extensively publicized.
- Left thousands of workers without union protection in the middle of the worst economic crisis of our lifetime by refusing to bargain more than 100 contracts and canceling extensions of dozens more.
Not like, say, the 50,000+ Kaiser Permanente members who had their futures and livelihoods sold down the river by Zombie UHW (as shown
here,
here and
here) or the 4700+ Sonoma county homecare workers who
had their fate sealed for the next 2 years.
What does the future hold for NUHW?
NUHW leaders will soon be going on trial in Federal Court.
Going to court does not mean a guaranteed guilty verdict.
In July, U.S district Judge William issued a preliminary injunction against NUHW leaders finding that they participated in a "broad-based scheme to take and destroy UHW property and information" contrary to the interests of the union members they once represented.
Who is saying the quoted phrase? It doesn't matter: one way it's an unsubstantiated allegation the other way it's a just nonsensical fear mongering.
Granted, in order to prevent the wholesale loss of faith and interest of its members worldwide SEIU has to
fight NUHW's advances but they could at least change their message to maintain appeal and relevance, unless of course they have nothing left to say.