Showing posts with label fingerprinting. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fingerprinting. Show all posts

Thursday, June 24, 2010

UDW excels where the Zombies fail

UDW, (United Domestic Workers), the counterpart to SEIU with respect to homecare workers in California have yet again succeeded where the Zombies have failed. The latest example of UDW shining through the muck of state politics and Zombie propaganda is this email I received. The absence of an email from is all the proof I need that the Zombie have abandoned homecare workers in the counties which UHW has contracts. The Zombie aren't even trying to help their dues paying members anymore any more. See Stern Burger's write up on yesterday's failure de jour! I wonder if Erica Boddie still has such an lofty of post trusteeship UHW.

Thursday, May 13, 2010

Fingerprinting of homecare consumers finally illegal!

Thanks to the unanimous decisions of Assembly Budget Subcommittee #1 on Health and Human Services, chair Assemblymembers Wes Chesbro, Jim Beall (both Democrats) Bob Emmerson and Brian Nestande (both Republicans) the fingerprinting for consumers as an anti-fraud measure is now illegal. Thanks to Marty Omoto for his timely report on this crucial decision.
California Budget Crisis:
Assembly Budget Subcommittee Votes to Rescind Fingerprinting Requirement of IHSS Recipients – Follows Senate Budget Subcommittee Action Last Week
Law Remains In Force Until Full Legislature and Governor Approve It As Part of 2010-2011 State Budget

SACRAMENTO, CALIF (CDCAN) [Updated 05/12/2010  02:50 PM  (Pacific Time)] – The Assembly Budget Subcommittee #1 on Health and Human Services, chaired by Assemblymember Wes Chesbro (Democrat – Eureka, 1st Assembly District) voted  4 to 0 this afternoon to rescind the state law passed as part of the 2009-2010 State Budget last July that requires the fingerprinting of all recipients receiving In-Home Supportive Services (IHSS).  Note: the final vote could change if any missing subcommittee members add their votes to the roll call. 

The action was supported by Democrats Chesbro and Assemblymember Jim Beall and also the subcommittee’s two Republican members, Assemblymember Bob Emmerson and Brian Nestande.

The motion by Assemblymember Chesbro would reject the $8.2 million currently in the 2009-2010 State Budget and $5.6 million funding proposed in the 2010-2011 State Budget and any additional associated funding for purposes of fingerprinting IHSS recipients and shift any unspent money into the budget of the Department of Social Services.  Chesbro’s motion would also create corresponding budget related language (referred to as “budget trailer bill”) that would rescind current state law requiring fingerprinting of all IHSS recipients and also state law that requires their fingerprints on all timesheets of their IHSS worker (provider). 

The action follows a similar vote last week by the Senate Budget Subcommittee #3 on Health and Human Services chaired by Sen. Mark Leno (Democrat – San Francisco).

What The Action Means
·         The action by both subcommittees today and last week is not final and still needs approval of the entire State Senate and Assembly -  and then approval of the Governor.  Those approvals will be part of any overall agreement for the 2010-2011 State Budget which, given the enormous budget deficit, will likely be months away. 
·         The action today would rescind or repeal state law – and the funding to implement it – the requirement for mandatory fingerprinting of all recipients who receive IHSS.  The current state law does allow for certain exemptions of the requirement.  However the fingerprinting law still remains in force until final action on this is given by the full Legislature and approved by the Governor as part of the 2010-2011 State Budget.
·         The requirement to fingerprint all IHSS recipients has not been implemented yet by the Department of Social Services – the state agency that oversees the IHSS program statewide, but is proceeding forward as a pilot in certain parts of the state.  If the full Legislature and Governor end up giving final approval of today’s subcommittee action, the effort to move forward on the pilot would end. 
·         The action today did not address and does not impact the fingerprinting and background checks requirements of IHSS workers (providers) that was  passed as part of the 2009-2010 State Budget last July.  Those requirements went into effect on November 1st and is underway now.

Friday, March 19, 2010

Despite being $20 billion in the hole, Governor finds way to harrass IHSS consumers

I guess it isn't enough that the Governor has had IHSS providers (workers) in his crosshairs since the day he took office. Apparently our (both providers and consumers (clients)) mere existence is unacceptable. Always looking for a new and devastating way to burn his fellow Californians, he's going after IHSS consumers (clients). You know, the low income elderly and disabled not to mention usually frail neighbors and family we care for that are our neighbors, friends and family. My friend's who cares for his father with dementia, my wife with Cerebral Palsy, my friend who cares for her child with Spina Bifida these are the latest group he's added to his list of usual suspects. This man has no conscious: he'll attack the poor and weak to perpetuate the illusion his efforts are saving money. But as I've written before the pennies he's saving are far outweighed by the dollars he's spending. Take, for example, the $3.5 million spent in Sacramento County to find fraud. Nineteen cases of fraud were detected for their efforts. That is a monumental waste of our, the taxpayers, money and an affront to 99% of honest IHSS providers. Now his administration is mulling over the purchase several hundred of these "MorphoTrak 'mobile biometric identification' device[s]". I checked out their website and found 2 devices that seem to fit the description in the Sacramento Bee article. Clearly this is speculative, but these devices seem overpriced and are more like mobile homecare terrorizing devices. Take your pick. What's next: a 1984-esque television that watches back?


See, if the guy gathering your information just smiles at you  it's make the criminalization of your job/disability so much easier to swallow! Seriously what a condescending smirk!

Or how about this one. Why not just go for broke and bring a lie detector to every consumer's house?



I see a few problems with the devices and their use. Here in Sonoma county, and I presume other organized counties, the contract between the county and the union reaffirms the long standing (e.g. before unionization) consumer right to "[d]etermine in advance and under all circumstances who may and may not enter their home." This is from section 3.1 (A) (3) of all contracts since we became organized in Sonoma county. What if a consumer can't come to the door? Hmmmmm. This privacy clause applies to unannounced house visits, but the Zombies are too busy hiring an army of lawyers from 4 law firms to fight NUHW in court next week to care about what really matters.

Second is the cost of these devices. These devices appear to be functionally equivalent to what I've listed below, at a price well below the 5 grand estimated cost of these mobile terrorizing units. Is this the best the Governator can come up with to fight fraud and save money? He can have both without spending a fortune of taxpayers money (which is not his money).

Finger print scanner: $39-$64
Digital camera: $29 & up
Netbook (a stripped down notebook computer): $250 & up (or better yet this one)

Add them up and what do you get, outside of a vendor who found a pot of gold hiding in the state budget?


 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
\ /


$318 (just under $350 with tax)

The software to operate the fingerprint reader is included with the reader itself and any computer from 2001 forward can retrieve pictures from a digital camera with any additional software.

Finally, as stated in the article the new legislation does not mention photographing consumers. Sounds like the State is getting in on the harassment of consumers normally performed by fraudsters.


So it appears that yet again the Governator's plans to destroy homecare will cost far money than it can ever hope to save. I'm so happy he's terming out of office next year.

Sunday, March 7, 2010

FREE fingerprinting for homecare workers in Lake Co...

...so will Sonoma County follow suit? Guess who I'm emailing and calling Monday morning. For my readers especially homecare providers (workers) and consumers (clients) in Sonoma County please call your supervisor as listed below. Don't know which district you are in? Look up your supervisor by street address. We need to raise their consciousness about the cost of proving our innocence.

They can all be reached at (707) 565-2241

District 1: Valerie Brown, vbrown@sonoma-county.org (southeast county)
District 2: Mike Kerns, mkerns@sonoma-county.org (southwest county)
District 3: Shirlee Zane, szane@sonoma-county.org (Santa Rosa & east Rohnert Park)
District 4: Paul Kelley, pkelley@sonoma-county.org (northeast county)
District 5: Efren Carrillo, ecarrillo@sonoma-county.org (northwest county)

Wednesday, February 10, 2010

Homecare fraud: you're lucky if you can find it!

Recently there has been some press coverage about homecare fraud with nearly all of it being bad. If we didn't get bad press we'd get no press at all. It seems the nature and cost effectiveness of homecare is horribly misunderstood. If you follow the LameStream media's coverage of this attack on homecare you'd think that the disabled poor and those who care for them are criminals worthy of only the harshest treatment. Following the Governator's line of reasoning one might think were it not for homecare the State wouldn't have a budget deficit at all! Here's an example of the spoon-fed and lopsided thinking that makes my blood boil.

 

This is exactly what we don't need: division among the consumers (clients) as to who is eligible. Having met several homecare providers (workers) and their consumers I can tell you if a consumer is receiving homecare services it's vital to the well-being and happiness of the consumer. My wife is much happier living with me than living in a group home! Homecare is no road to riches for the providers and it saves the State far more than it would spend if it housed every consumer in a nursing home, group home or whatever dungeon they think the disabled poor should be warehoused in.

When legislators and journalists stop blindly accepting what someone else tells them is the irrefutable truth (the Gov tells the Legislature, and the journalists gobble up whatever they hear from Sacramento) and the State attempst to find the fraud, they find much less fraud exists than is reported by the media. In 2007, the Gov stated it was as high as 25%, but when investigated by his own administration it was found to be no more than 1%. Don't get me wrong: even 1% is unacceptable but the way the State is going about reducing fraud is Draconian, and obviously lopsided (which is putting it nicely). For those who choose to abuse the system and steal from both us the taxpayers and us the overwhelmingly majority of honest workers just trying to earn a living, I say hang them up by their ampersand caret asterisk toes in the middle of town.

The money spent to detect and stop fraud is ridiculous in both absolute dollars and when the amount of money recovered is divided into the amount spent finding the fraud in the first place. Here are some examples:

 

Did y'all get that: they spent $3 million to save $315,000! That's $157,894.74 per conviction! I thought the Zombies' dollar-to-vote ratio was out of control but this is ridiculous! A quick run crunching the numbers shows this was a prime example of the State's penny-wise but pound-foolish approach to handling our tax money.
Maximum number of hours that can be assigned to any one consumer: 283 (a 40 work week is 173 hours a month, 283 is ~1.6 times more)
Hourly wage for IHSS workers in Sacramento: $10.40
Months in a year: 12
A years worth of homecare work at the above given wage comes out to $35,318.40
Difference between cost per conviction and maximum payout for one consumer's worth of work (283 x 10.40 x 12=): $110,576.34.

I say (s)he who wastes more money gets required lifetime employment at McDonald's working the drive thru window!

So, yet again way more money is spent than is recovered, but at least the politicians can feel good about their efforts to root out the fraud. Sheesh, does it hurt to be this stupid?

This is not an isolated example of the State's overzealous attack on the poor and defenseless.

 

So as you can see the State is very concerned about the 0.2% (NOT 2%!) in over-payments in Fresno county, the State's leader in homecare fraud detection, prevention and conviction and the only way they can see to fix the problem and punish this despicable and very small group of scamming "caregivers" is to take us all down. Make the poor poorer (reduce us to minimum wage), punish the innocent (fingerprinting for all), surely that will solve all our problems!

So to combat this problem they've written the "improvements" below into law. As far as I know they have yet to figure out how to implement these new laws. What the State has in mind is indeed punitive:
  • checks can't be mailed to P.O. boxes (which is a bummer because in my neighborhood, a P.O. box is an excellent way to prevent identity theft)
  • fingerprints for both the provider and consumer put on each timecard (Who pays for the ink? Who is charged with matching 800,000+ fingerprints to people on a semi-monthly basis? What if a consumer doesn't have (accessible) thumbs? Whatever happened to "innocent until proven guilty"?)
  • State required but not funded fingerprinting for both consumers and providers (and where were the Zombies when these proposal became law? Busy fighting with members, again!)
  • unannounced home visits (Which seem to be in violation of  multiple homecare contracts about the consumer's right to chose whom, how and when someone enters their home.)
Seems like overkill doesn't it?

A few things need to be said about fraud:
  • fraud is wrong, no matter the justification or significance
  • those who commit fraud, both providers and (living) consumers must be punished
  • the rest of us who aren't committing fraud need to be left alone, no fingerprinting at our own expense to prove our innocence
  • the folks handling the timecards (counties) and the folks who cut the checks (the State) need some simple checks to be put in place, specifically:
  • no checks for the consumers known to be deceased (except for consumers who passed away mid pay period)
  • no checks for providers or consumers who are in jail
Had the counties and the State been checking for this all along who knows how much money could have been saved. Consider the lack of seething animosity that could have been avoided. The oft reported, but grossly exaggerated costs of IHSS fraud could simply never have happened but for that you'd need a state that cares for it's elderly and disabled poor, instead of taking every possible action to move us both ever-faster into the grave. Even when these fraudsters are caught it's a great expense to the State and the money is not always recovered.

Fortunately for us all the writing of a few bright minds makes it's way to the Op-Ed sections of our newspapers and blogs.


Indeed, this is a rare voice of reason is a sea of stupity.

Tuesday, October 27, 2009

CDCAN: Joint Informational Hearing by Legislature October 28

Again message wasn't emailed to me until 12:07 today and I didn't read it until 3:30-ish. So, this is almost too late to act on but here it is. Comments that are underlined were underlined by me.

Implementation of IHSS Budget Reductions and Policy Changes Focus of Joint Informational Hearing By Legislature October 28th
Joint Hearing by Assembly Budget Committee and Senate Budget Subcommittee #3 on Health and Human Services Will Hear From 4 Panels on Reported Widespread Problems and Concerns – No Public Testimony But Comment Cards and Letters Will Be Taken

SACRAMENTO, CALIF (CDCAN) [Updated 10/27/09  11:20 AM  (Pacific Time)  - With major concerns and problems being reported across the state on the implementation of budget reductions and policy changes to the In-Home Supportive Services (IHSS) program impacting over 450,000 children and adults with disabilities, mental health needs, the blind and low income seniors, a joint hearing of the Assembly Budget Committee and the Senate Budget Subcommittee #3 on Health and Human Services, is scheduled for Wednesday, October 28, 2009, at 1:00 PM at the State Capitol in Room 4202.   

The unusual joint hearing of the Assembly Budget Committee – chaired by Assemblymember Noreen Evans (Democrat – Santa Rosa) and the Senate Budget Subcommittee #3 on Health and Human Services – chaired by State Sen. Mark Leno (Democrat – San Francisco), should be televised by Cal Channel or viewed on the Cal Channel website at www.calchannel.com [CDCAN will issue a full report immediately following the hearing]

The IHSS cuts and policy changes also impact hundreds of thousands of IHSS workers and the families of the IHSS recipients, counties, community based organizations and regional centers. 

The IHSS budget reductions and program changes – along with major cuts to other health and human service programs including regional centers, Medi-Cal and other areas of the state budget - were made this year as part of the effort by the Legislature and Governor to close a budget gap of over $40  billion in February – and over $23 billion in July. 

Hearing Comes After Federal Court Rulings Stopping Some Cuts
The joint committee hearing comes after recent federal court rulings in late June, and earlier this month that stopped two of the major budget reductions to the IHSS program that would have narrowed eligibility and reduced domestic and related services using a little known assessment scoring and ranking tool, and a reduction in state funding toward IHSS worker wages.  While the State is appealing both rulings to the USth Circuit Court of Appeals, the federal court required the Schwarzenegger Administration to comply and stop those cuts immediately.

Other Lawsuits Filed or Being Considered On IHSS Cuts
A state lawsuit filed in State Superior Court to stop the elimination of the IHSS “share of cost buy-out” program that was eliminated October 1 as part of the revised 2009-2010 State Budget passed by the Legislature and signed by the Governor in late July, is pending – though prospects for the state court to intervene at this stage does not appear good at this point.

Other lawsuits are being considered or are moving forward, though not yet filed, impacting the IHSS worker background checks, unannounced home visits by state agencies to homes of IHSS recipients and possibly fingerprinting requirements of both IHSS workers and recipients.    

Concerns Raised About November 1st Implementation of Other IHSS Cuts
Other reductions – including new requirements for background checks and fingerprinting of IHSS workers, elimination of the “share of cost buy-out” program – have either gone into effect or will go into effect November 1st.

Several counties have sent official letters to the Schwarzenegger Administration indicating major concerns and problems in trying to meet the November 1, 2009 deadline to implement new budget related requirements for IHSS workers (sometimes known as “providers”) and for persons receiving IHSS.  Some counties indicated that they would be unable to implement any of the new requirements until the Department of Social Services – the state agency within the Schwarzenegger Administration that oversees the IHSS program – sends out additional details that the counties say are critical in carrying out the new worker and recipient requirements. 

Other issues raised by advocacy groups and the counties included concerns regarding the various notices from the Department of Social Services containing instructions and guidelines to implement the various reductions and policy changes (contained in documents called “All County Letters” and “All County Information Notices”). 


A CDCAN Townhall Telemeeting held October 21 with representatives of various statewide and local advocacy groups and individuals attracted hundreds of people across the State that brought up reports of widespread confusion, panic and concerns regarding the IHSS budget reductions and program changes. [a complete audio recording of that townhall telemeeting is available for free on the CDCAN website at www.cdcan.us ]

Hearing Will Focus on Implementation Issues
Those issues – along with others related to the IHSS program will be heard in the October 28th informational hearing by the Assembly Budget Committee.  No formal action or vote will be taken at that hearing. 

No public testimony – other than those coming from people from the various panels scheduled to provide information to the committee – will be taken.  However the committee will take comments from the general public via comment cards that will be available at the hearing, or through letters to the committee office. 

Assembly Budget Committee
Attention: Assemblymember Noreen Evans, Chair
State Capitol
Sacramento, CA 95814

Senate Budget Subcommittee #3 on Health and Human Services
Attention: Sen. Mark Leno, Chair
State Capitol
Sacramento, CA 95814

The joint committee agenda for the hearing October 28th is (for official copy of the agenda below and for background paper for this hearing, and copies of the county letters to the State, and background documents of this hearing, go to the CDCAN website at www.cdcan.us)

ASSEMBLY BUDGET COMMITTEE AND THE SENATE BUDGET SUBCOMMITTEE NO. 3 ON HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES
Oversight Hearing on Implementation of Recent Changes in the In-Home Supportive Services Program
Wednesday, October 28, 2009 – State Capitol Room 4202

AGENDA
I. Overview of Recent Program Changes in the In-Home Supportive Services Program IHSS
Ginni Bella, Legislative Analyst's Office
II. State Implementation Process and Outcomes
·         John Wagner, Director, California Department of Social Services (DSS)
·         Eva Lopez, Deputy Director, Adult Programs Division, DSS
III. County Concerns and Feedback on Capacity to Implement Changes
·         Frank Mecca, Executive Director, County Welfare Directors Association of California
·         Diane Kaljian, Adult and Aging Services Director, Sonoma County Human Services Department
IV. Reaction Panel and Impact of Implementation on Consumers
·         Deborah Doctor, Legislative Advocate, Disability Rights California [formerly Protection and Advocacy Inc or PAI]
·         Jovan Agee, Political & Legislative Director, United Domestic Workers of America / AFSCME
·         Laphonza Butler, Co-Trustee, Service Employees International Union – United Long Term Care Workers
·         Donna Calame, Executive Director, San Francisco IHSS Public Authority

Comment cards will be available and received at the hearing from members of the public who would like to submit written testimony.