Showing posts with label raid. Show all posts
Showing posts with label raid. Show all posts

Sunday, November 29, 2009

Surly comment gets its own blog entry!

I received this comment today from a reader who completely missed the point of my Blast from the Past: Stern's words come back to haunt him! post. I was trying to point out how SEIU's actions of yesteryear are in perfect contradiction to it's actions of late as they relate to Memorial hospital. How dare you criticize my writing while not reading the blog entry thoroughly and then reading the referenced article. I thought I was explicit enough.
Wouldn't an even slightly honest account have at least mentioned the fact that, despite this dispute between SEIU and CNA/NNOC, CNA/NNOC has now sided with SEIU against NUHW? Of course, if that fact had been mentioned, it would have had to have been explained away--either by denigrating CNA/NNOC (which would have made CNA/NNOC not quite look like the champion of workers' rights portrayed by this blog post) or by excusing this choice by CNA/NNOC as reasonable (which would only be true if SEIU was seen as the winner as in the long run). If DeMoro's criticism of SEIU gets an "Amen, sister", doesn't her acceptance of SEIU over NUHW rate the same respect?

Also, why isn't it NUHW that should get used to losing? That's pretty much all that's happened so far.
So in response to this comment I will clarify my writing. 

The CNA/SEIU alliance benefits all 3 parties: CNA doesn't have to deal with SEIU's raids (or active probing as SEIU likes to spin it), NUHW gets a $1 million gift and an agreement not to interfere with NUHW's efforts SEIU has a friend to play with bringing the friend count to 2. However, with the way things are going for SEIU and nearly every other labor organization CNA might want to distance itself from the devil.

As for NUHW losing I have a few truths to share with my woefully (and likely willingly) underinformed reader:
  1. when SEIU ties up election results with the NLRB, that's not a victory! 
  2. Sequoias caregivers join NUHW
  3. Los Alamitos Hospital join National Union of Healthcare Workers  
  4. Workers win election at Doctor's San Pablo 
  5. Union calls off bid to represent workers at Rady
The truth is out there, if you care.